Jacques Distler has a new posting about multi-loop string amplitudes. It’s mainly devoted to the Berkovits superstring formalism, and explains in some detail the possible problems with this formalism that one might worry about. I’d alluded to some of these in the comment section of my posting about this last week, responding to commenters claiming that Berkovits had a proof of finiteness of multi-loop amplitudes. At the time, all I got in response was abuse about how ignorant I was. Presumably the same people will be either showering Jacques with abuse, or apologizing to me. Funny, for some reason Distler doesn’t mention what I’d written about this. He also seems to have somehow neglected to put “Not Even Wrong” in his list of links to physics weblogs.
About
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions (under construction)Not Even Wrong: The Book
Categories
- Book Reviews (25)
- BRST (12)
- Experimental HEP News (105)
- Langlands (11)
- Multiverse Mania (60)
- Not Even Wrong: The Book (26)
- This Week's Hype (59)
- Uncategorized (866)
Recent Comments
- Short Items 44
Peter Woit, Thomas, Thomas, Chris Oakley, Thomas, Allan Rosenberg [...] - The Langlands Program and Quantum Field Theory 7
Peter Woit, Mike, Ossicle, Peter Woit, Ossicle, Peter Woit [...] - An Introduction to Group Therapy for Particle Physics 20
Jon, former mathematician, Jeff M, Chirag, Belastingvrije auto's, Thingumbobesquire [...] - What is your favorite deep, elegant, or beautiful explanation? 44
chiz, jorge, harryb, Peter Woit, D R Lunsford, Alberto [...] - Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Field Theory 6
Igor Khavkine, Marcus, Tim van Beek, Peter Woit, Igor Khavkine, David Roberts
- Short Items 44
Archives
Links
Mathematics Weblogs
- Alexandre Borovik
- Antwerp Nonommutative Geometry Seminar
- Automorphic Forum
- Cathy O'Neil
- Concrete Nonsense
- Danny Calegari
- Emmanuel Kowalski
- Jeffrey Morton
- Jesse Johnson
- Johan deJong
- Lieven Le Bruyn
- London Number Theory
- Motivic Stuff
- Noncommutative Geometry
- Quomodocumque
- Rigorous Trivialities
- Secret Blogging Seminar
- Terence Tao
- The n-Category Cafe
- Timothy Gowers
Physics Weblogs
- Alexey Petrov
- Andrew Jaffe
- Angry Physicist
- Capitalist Imperialist Pig
- Chad Orzel
- Charles Day
- Christine Dantas
- Clifford Johnson
- Cormac O’Raifeartaigh
- Cosmic Variance
- Dmitry Podolsky
- Doug Natelson
- EPMG Blog
- Georg von Hippel
- Gordon Watts
- Jacques Distler
- Jennifer Ouellette
- Jim Rohlf
- John Horgan
- John Terning
- Jonathan Shock
- Lubos Motl
- Makoto Sakurai
- Martin Perl
- Matt Strassler
- Michael Schmitt
- Philip Gibbs
- Physics World
- Resonaances
- Robert Helling
- Sabine Hossenfelder/Stefan Scherer
- Scott Aaronson
- Shores of the Dirac Sea
- Steve Hsu
- Sujit Datta
- Tommaso Dorigo
Meta

Dear Peter,
I think that your comments are relatively far from those of Jacques, although – I hope that Jacques won’t be terribly offended – they’re not infinitely far.
Best
Lubos