Monthly Archives: October 2006

Some Early Criticism of String Theory

From the “First Superstring Revolution” on, there have always been skeptics, even though they often were not very vocal. Perhaps the most well-known piece of such criticism was Paul Ginsparg and Sheldon Glashow’s Desperately Seeking Superstrings, which appeared in the … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 77 Comments

Again, Is N=8 Supergravity Finite?

The main argument generally given for working on string theory is that it’s the only way to get a finite theory of quantum gravity. One often hears claims that gravity can’t be quantized using QFT, that string theory is needed … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 12 Comments

The Proof is in the Blogging

Seed has a new article out by Stephen Ornes, called The Proof is in the Blogging, about the way the story of Penny Smith’s solution to the Navier-Stokes problem played out here. I’m quite fond of the photo included in … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 9 Comments

Fit To Be Tied

This week’s Science News has a quite good article about the string theory controversy by Peter Weiss, unfortunately available on-line only to subscribers. The title is “Fit to be Tied: Impatience with string theory boils over”. There’s nothing much in … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 8 Comments

Some Links

Earlier this month there was a workshop on twisted K-theory held at Oberwolfach. Here is a report, also slides from a talk there by Greg Landweber about the Freed-Hopkins-Teleman theorem. Freed is giving a course on the subject this fall, … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 13 Comments

Finite Generation of the Canonical Ring

The last few weeks have seen the appearance of two papers giving very different proofs of a quite important result in algebraic geometry, resolving a question that had been open for a very long time, and in the process helping … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 6 Comments

Prospects For a String Theory Phenomenology

Yesterday at the KITP Michael Dine gave a very good survey talk on Prospects for a String Theory Phenomenology. It’s pretty much hype free, has a much more realistic point of view than most talks on string phenomenology that I’ve … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 44 Comments

The Hype Goes On

The Ottawa Citizen today has an Op-Ed by string cosmologist Jim Cline, headlined The Big Idea That Won’t Die, with a subtitle “The fact that string theory is suddenly under attack only underscores its success as a path to a … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | 40 Comments

King of Infinite Space

Back when I was a graduate student trying to figure out how to define and calculate topological charge in lattice gauge theory, at one point I went over to the math department to ask some people I knew if they … Continue reading

Posted in Book Reviews | 29 Comments

The String Wars

I noticed recently that George Johnson will be journalist in residence and giving a talk on Friday at the KITP in Santa Barbara about “The String Wars”. Somehow I don’t really think that it’s a good thing that this is … Continue reading

Posted in Favorite Old Posts, Uncategorized | 97 Comments