Student Geometric & Analysis Seminar (Spring 2023): Scalar Curvature and Dihedral Rigidity

Organizers: Tsz-Kiu Aaron Chow, Jingbo Wan, Yipeng Wang

Time: Wednesdays 3:10 pm—5:10 pm

Location:  Room 528 at Columbia Math Department

This seminar dedicates to providing a survey about some known results and open questions related to the structure of Riemannian manifolds with scalar curvature bounded from below. Such manifolds seem could be characterized using metric geometric objects such as polyhedron comparison arguments via dihedral angles between adjacent weakly mean convex faces.  And those phenomena motivate the program proposed by Gromov, to study the delicate effect of scalar curvature on Riemannian manifolds through the shape of more singular metric spaces, namely the Dihedral Rigidity Conjecture. At the same time, we will introduce various analytic techniques such as constructing free boundary minimal hypersurfaces, establishing index theory for manifolds with corners, and solving certain elliptic boundary value problems. Applications in low-dimensional topology and mathematical physics will also be discussed if time permits. 

References: 

[B] Brendle Scalar Curvature Rigidity for Convex Polytopes

[BB11] B ̈ar, Ballmann Boundary Value Problems for Elliptic Differential Operators of First Order

[BB13] B ̈ar, Ballmann Guide to Boundary Value Problems for Dirac-Type Operators 

[G14] Gromov Dirac and Plateau Billiards in Domain with Corners

[G19] Gromov Four Lectures on Scalar Curvature

[G22] Gromov Convex Polytopes, Dihedral Angles, Mean Curvature, and Scalar Curvature 

[GL] Gromov, Lawson Spin and Scalar Curvature

[Li17] Li A Polyhedron Comparison Theorem for 3-Manifolds with Positive Scalar Curvature 

[Li19] Li The Dihedral Rigidity Conjecture for n-Prisms 

[WXY] Wang, Xie, Yu On Gromov’s Dihedral Extremality and Rigidity Conjectures


Title and Abstract (Spring 2023)

Date

Speaker

Title and abstract

Jan 25th


Organizational Meeting

Feb 1st

Yipeng Wang

The C^0 Limit Theorem for Scalar Curvature 

Show/hide Abstracts

The theory of taking limits of Riemannian manifolds is extensively studied given that certain curvature quantities are uniformly bounded from below. For instance, the theory of Alexandrov spaces is developed to study limit spaces with sectional curvature bounded from below, and similar situations apply to spaces with bounded Ricci curvature via Cheeger-Colding-Naber Theory. However, the corresponding results on scalar curvature are still far from being understood. Recently, Gromov proposed to study spaces with positive scalar curvature in terms of polyhedra and use it to prove the compactness theorem. We will discuss a simpler proof proposed via Ricci flow introduced by Bamler. At the same time, we will motivate the corresponding rigidity conjecture and some related questions about scalar curvature. 

 

Notes for the Talk 

 


Feb 8th

Yipeng Wang

More about the Dihedral Rigidity Problem 

Show/hide Abstracts

We will discuss more motivations for the dihedral rigidity problem and focus on some relations with general relativity. After that, I will sketch the proof of the conjecture for a large class of polyhedrons in dimension between 3 and 7 modulo the theory of capillary surfaces.  

 

Notes for the Talk 

 


Feb 15th

Jingbo Wan

Elliptic Boundary Value Problem for Dirac-Type Operators: Part 1 

Show/hide Abstracts

Dirac Operator is a powerful tool to study positive scalar curvature. Concerning positive scalar curvature on a manifold with boundary, it’s natural to ask how to formulate a valid boundary value problem for Dirac operator (1st order elliptic). In fact, Dirichlet boundary condition, which is natural for Laplacian operator (2nd order elliptic), turns out to be too strong for 1st order elliptic operators. In this talk, we focus on Dirac-type operators, with principal symbols capturing the Clifford relation just like the usual Dirac operator, and discuss some basic materials to get ready for elliptic boundary value problems. 

 

Reference: [BB11] [BB13] 

 


Feb 22nd

Tin Yau Tsang (UC Irvine)

Foliation by Perturbation 

Show/hide Abstracts

We would study the metric perturbation technique by Chodosh-Eichmair. From this, one can form a foliation of prescribed mean curvature surface which provides rigidity under scalar curvature assumption. 

 

 


Mar 1st

Jingbo Wan

Elliptic Boundary Value Problem for Dirac-Type Operators: Part 2 

Show/hide Abstracts

Last time, we defined the differential operator on the boundary associated to the given Dirac type operator using the information of the symbols. Recall that such associated boundary operator is a self-adjoint elliptic first order operator defined on a closed manifold (the boundary), so we can make use of its spectrum (L^2 decomposition of sections defined on the boundary) to investigate what kind of boundary condition is natural for the Dirac type operator. Statements will be given and the ideas of the proof will be sketched, and some important examples will be discussed. 

 

Reference: [BB11] [BB13] 

 


Mar 8th

No seminar (Department Colloquim)

Mar 15th

No seminar (Spring break)

Mar 22nd

Jingbo Wan

Elliptic Boundary Value Problem for Dirac-Type Operators: Part 3 

Show/hide Abstracts

Last time, we studied the hybrid Sobolev spaces using the spectrum of a boundary adapted operator. In particular, the hybrid Sobolev space $\check{H}(A)$ is the image of (extended) trace map on the Dirac-maximal domain, and any boundary condition we will consider is a closed subspace of $\check{H}(A)$. Among all the boundary conditions, a special class called D-elliptic boundary conditions will be the main subject we are discussing. To understand this D-elliptic boundary condition, we will start with the famous APS condition, and try to explore based on that. Under these D-elliptic boundary conditions, nice boundary regularity result is obtained. And we will also discuss many other examples which belong to the class of D-elliptic boundary conditions. 

 

Reference: [BB11] [BB13] 

 


Mar 29th

Yipeng Wang

Eigenvalue of Schrödinger Equations 

Show/hide Abstracts

I will discuss a theorem originally due to Professor Fefferman and Phong, which is about the estimate of the lowest eigenvalue of Schrödinger equations with weak regularity assumptions on the potentials. In particular, we will look at the situations where the potential is small in a Morrey norm and how this is applied to the dihedral rigidity problem in Professor Brendle's work. 

 

Notes for the Talk 

 


Apr 5th

No seminar (Department Colloquim)

Apr 12th

Jingbo Wan

Isoperimetric surface technique & Volumne Comparison theorems 

Show/hide Abstracts

In this talk, we will discuss the isoperimetric surface technique that was developed by Professor Hubert Bray in his PhD thesis. In particular, we are going to use such technique to study volume comparison theorems for positively curved manifolds, which includes a new proof for the Bishop’ volume comparison theorem and also the “Bray’s football theorem”- a volume comparison theorem for scalar curvature in the case that the metric is close to the standard S^3 metric. We remark that the rigid case of Bray’s football theorem can be found in a beautiful survey paper written by Professor S.Brendle. (But we might not have the time cover it) 

 

Reference:  

H. Bray, PhD thesis  

S. Brendle, Rigidity phenomena involving scalar curvature 

 


Apr 19th

Jingbo Wan

Isoperimetric surface technique & Penrose Inequality 

Show/hide Abstracts

In this talk, we will continue to discuss the isoperimetric surface technique that was developed by Professor Hubert Bray in his PhD thesis. This time, we are going to study the effect of non-negativity of scalar curvature on a complete asymptotically flat three-manifold. In particular, we will use the isoperimetric surface technique to prove two conditional Penrose inequality for single/multiple horizons cases. In contrast to last time, we are dealing with a minimizing process in non-compact manifolds, so we need to address the existence of area minimizers with its volume constraint. 

 

Reference:  

H. Bray, PhD thesis  

S. Brendle, Rigidity phenomena involving scalar curvature 

 


Apr 26th

Aaron Chow

Rigidity of convex polytopes under the dominant energy condition 

Show/hide Abstracts

Abstract: In this talk, we will discuss a rigidity theorem for initial data sets corresponding to convex polytopes, which adhere to the dominant energy condition. To demonstrate the theorem, we employ a technique that entails approximating the target polytope using smooth convex domains and subsequently tackling a boundary value problem involving Dirac operators on these specific domains. This is a follow-up work of Brendle’s recent result.